Posted by on Nov 16, 2009 in book review, Jim Murdoch, nanowrimo | 3 Comments

Sooo… the things I wanted to talk about:

Jim Murdoch’s new novel, Stranger than Fiction. I really enjoyed this, and Jim’s profoundly idiosyncratic view of the world is always fascinating. I tried to come up with one of those pithy one-liners that you are supposed to use to encapsulate a project for the movie industry (which is popularly supposed not to be able to cope with more than a sentence of information at a time) and what I decided on was Alan Bennett meets Douglas Adams! The characters from Jim’s previous novel are resurrected, having died at the end of the last one, in a manner not unreminiscent (is that a word?) of Eoin Colfer’s continuation of the work of said Douglas Adams. I loved it. Jim’s novel, I mean, not Eoin’s – haven’t read that and probably won’t – I’m not sure why I don’t like writers picking up the work of deceased literary stars and taking it on, but I don’t.

Writers who won’t – don’t get me started! I have been talking to a writer for seven months (seven!) about a project that she’s capable of achieving and has all mapped out, but she just can’t bring herself to start. Way back in 2006 Fortune Magazine’s Geoffrey Colvin wrote an article highlighting research that shows that the gap between success and failure is filled by practice and consistent feedback on the quality of that practice. Now I’m not a great fan of workshops, because I think they become an end in themselves for many people, but if some writers just used a quarter of the time they spend thinking and talking about their work on actually getting words down, they would develop some of that practice and might find that not only did their ability to work improve, but the work itself did too.

But then there are writers who won’t stop. I feel guilt every November when I watch some talented writers diving into NaNoWriMo with flailing abandon. You see, when I was a NaNo coordinator I pushed a lot of these people into their November excess and now I watch in horror this one and only time of the year that they write anything at all. It’s an unintended by-product of NaNo frenzy that some writers find they can’t get into the habit of writing all year round, or writing without the plaudits and excitement of the massive social network that surrounds the event. And this means that in November they are happy to produce 50 or 70 or even 90 thousand words that they put in a drawer and forget about. It’s as if they store up all their writing stimulus through the year to splurge it out in one great orgy of unstoppable wordiness. Okay, it’s not my problem (I’m not a coordinator any more, for one thing) but it does worry me more than a little that NaNo might be destroying writers rather than creating them. Anybody else got any evidence, especially to disprove my theory that a few writers can only perform under NaNo stimulus?

And I was going to blog about an average day in my life, but it’s too depressing to contemplate the deadlines looming over me right now, so I shall save it for next time.

The picture shows Morgan, formerly known as Toulouse, but she wouldn’t answer to it …

3 Comments

  1. Jim Murdoch
    16th November 2009

    I can live with that. I’ve had exactly the same problem myself. Of course when I wrote both novels I had never read either. But you’re quite right. When I wrote my short stories I was very much enthralled by Bennett’s Talking Heads not that I copied him but he really reinvigorated the monologue for me. I was actually disappointed by the novelisation of The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy when I read it. It really is a very straightforward book. I don’t know what I was expecting but what I got were the radio scripts novelised. I should really read one of his later books to see how he does on his own.

    Anyway I’m delighted you enjoyed the thing. That’s it by the way. This is going to have to be a trilogy in two parts I’m afraid.

    Reply
  2. Elisabeth
    17th November 2009

    I agree, Jim’s writing is marvelous and original in the way his vice picks up on others who precede him that morphs onto a new work, uniquely Jim.

    As for your comments about some writers needing workshops in which to write, otherwise they can’t get motivated, I’ve observed this too.

    I like to use workshops as a springboard for writing. Certainly there’s something about the workshop buzz that can make me produce in ways I might otherwise not, but as you say not as an end in itself.

    Writers write. It’s as simple as that. Those who think about writing but do not put their thoughts down become would-be writers.

    Reply
  3. Anonymous
    19th November 2009

    No stack blown but actually like the sound of it….! – EA

    Reply

Leave a Reply